Post by nickd on Mar 9, 2012 23:46:10 GMT 1
LORD BACH
LORD PANNICK
LORD ALTON OF LIVERPOOL
LORD NEWTON OF BRAINTREE
Amendment (12)
Page 125, line 5, at end insert—
“Social welfare law (No. 2)
(1) Civil legal services provided in respect of a social welfare decision relating to a benefit, allowance, payment, credit or pension under—
(a) the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992;
(b) the Jobseekers Act 1995;
(c) the State Pension Credit Act 2002;
(d) the Tax Credits Act 2002;
(e) the Welfare Reform Act 2007;
(f) the Welfare Reform Act 2012; or
(g) any other enactment relating to social security.
(2) For the purposes of sub-paragraph (1), “civil legal services” includes—
(a) independent advice or assistance for an appeal to a second-tier tribunal; and
(b) independent advice, assistance and representation at a higher court of such a decision.”
LORD LLOYD OF BERWICK
Read more: mylegal.proboards.com/index.cgi?action=display&board=frontline&thread=598&page=1#1403#ixzz1ofAgYU2s
Here are the peers who voted against the amendment
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Anelay of St Johns
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Berridge
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Bottomley of Nettlestone
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Browning
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Buscombe
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Byford
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Eaton
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Eccles of Moulton
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Fookes
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Gardner of Parkes
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Hanham
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Heyhoe Flint
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Hooper
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Jenkin of Kennington
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Knight of Collingtree
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Miller of Hendon
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Morris of Bolton
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Neville-Jones
Con ------ no ------ Baroness O'Cathain
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Perry of Southwark
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Rawlings
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Seccombe
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Shackleton of Belgravia
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Sharples
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Shephard of Northwold
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Stedman-Scott
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Stowell of Beeston
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Trumpington
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Verma
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Warsi
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Wheatcroft
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Wilcox
Con ------ no ------ Earl Attlee
Con ------ no ------ Earl Cathcart
Con ------ no ------ Earl Howe
Con ------ no ------ Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon
Con ------ no ------ Lord Ashton of Hyde
Con ------ no ------ Lord Astor of Hever
Con ------ no ------ Lord Baker of Dorking
Con ------ no ------ Lord Bates
Con ------ no ------ Lord Blencathra
Con ------ no ------ Lord Boswell of Aynho
Con ------ no ------ Lord Bowness
Con ------ no ------ Lord Brooke of Sutton Mandeville
Con ------ no ------ Lord Brougham and Vaux
Con ------ no ------ Lord Cavendish of Furness
Con ------ no ------ Lord Cope of Berkeley
Con ------ no ------ Lord Crathorne
Con ------ no ------ Lord Crickhowell
Con ------ no ------ Lord de Mauley
Con ------ no ------ Lord Deben
Con ------ no ------ Lord Denham
Con ------ no ------ Lord Dobbs
Con ------ no ------ Lord Eden of Winton
Con ------ no ------ Lord Edmiston
Con ------ no ------ Lord Elton
Con ------ no ------ Lord Faulks
Con ------ no ------ Lord Fellowes of West Stafford
Con ------ no ------ Lord Fink
Con ------ no ------ Lord Forsyth of Drumlean
Con ------ no ------ Lord Fowler
Con ------ no ------ Lord Framlingham
Con ------ no ------ Lord Freeman
Con ------ no ------ Lord Freud
Con ------ no ------ Lord Gardiner of Kimble
Con ------ no ------ Lord Geddes
Con ------ no ------ Lord Glendonbrook
Con ------ no ------ Lord Glentoran
Con ------ no ------ Lord Goodlad
Con ------ no ------ Lord Griffiths of Fforestfach
Con ------ no ------ Lord Hamilton of Epsom
Con ------ no ------ Lord Henley
Con ------ no ------ Lord Hill of Oareford
Con ------ no ------ Lord Howard of Rising
Con ------ no ------ Lord Howe of Aberavon
Con ------ no ------ Lord Hunt of Wirral
Con ------ no ------ Lord Inglewood
Con ------ no ------ Lord James of Blackheath
Con ------ no ------ Lord Jopling
Con ------ no ------ Lord King of Bridgwater
Con ------ no ------ Lord Lamont of Lerwick
Con ------ no ------ Lord Lawson of Blaby
Con ------ no ------ Lord Lexden
Con ------ no ------ Lord Lingfield
Con ------ no ------ Lord Luke
Con ------ no ------ Lord Lyell
Con ------ no ------ Lord MacGregor of Pulham Market
Con ------ no ------ Lord Marland
Con ------ no ------ Lord Marlesford
Con ------ no ------ Lord Mawhinney
Con ------ no ------ Lord Mayhew of Twysden
Con ------ no ------ Lord Moore of Lower Marsh
Con ------ no ------ Lord Norton of Louth
Con ------ no ------ Lord Patten
Con ------ no ------ Lord Popat
Con ------ no ------ Lord Ribeiro
Con ------ no ------ Lord Sanderson of Bowden
Con ------ no ------ Lord Sassoon
Con ------ no ------ Lord Selkirk of Douglas
Con ------ no ------ Lord Selsdon
Con ------ no ------ Lord Shaw of Northstead
Con ------ no ------ Lord Sheikh
Con ------ no ------ Lord Spicer
Con ------ no ------ Lord Strathclyde
Con ------ no ------ Lord Taylor of Holbeach
Con ------ no ------ Lord Trimble
Con ------ no ------ Lord True
Con ------ no ------ Lord Tugendhat
Con ------ no ------ Lord Wakeham
Con ------ no ------ Lord Wasserman
Con ------ no ------ The Duke of Montrose
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Arran
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Caithness
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Courtown
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Home
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Lindsay
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Liverpool
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Shrewsbury
Con ------ no ------ Viscount Bridgeman
Con ------ no ------ Viscount Eccles
Con ------ no ------ Viscount Goschen
Con ------ no ------ Viscount Trenchard
Con ------ no ------ Viscount Ullswater
Con ------ no ------ Viscount Younger of Leckie
Crossbench ------ no ------ Lord Butler of Brockwell
Crossbench ------ no ------ Lord Greenway
Crossbench ------ no ------ Lord Maginnis of Drumglass
Crossbench ------ no ------ Lord Mawson
Crossbench ------ no ------ Lord Powell of Bayswater
Crossbench ------ no ------ Lord Rogan
Crossbench ------ no ------ Viscount Craigavon
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Barker
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Benjamin
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Bonham-Carter of Yarnbury
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Brinton
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Falkner of Margravine
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Garden of Frognal
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Hamwee
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Hussein-Ece
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Jolly
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Kramer
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Linklater of Butterstone
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Maddock
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Miller of Chilthorne Domer
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Northover
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Randerson
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Scott of Needham Market
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Sharp of Guildford
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Thomas of Winchester
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Tyler of Enfield
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Walmsley
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Williams of Crosby
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Addington
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Alderdice
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Bradshaw
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Burnett
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Chidgey
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Clement-Jones
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Dholakia
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Dykes
LDem ------ no ------ Lord German
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Goodhart
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Hussain
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Jones of Cheltenham
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Loomba
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Macdonald of River Glaven
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames
LDem ------ no ------ Lord McNally
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Methuen
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Newby
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Palmer of Childs Hill
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Razzall
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Redesdale
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Rennard
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Roberts of Llandudno
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Sharkey
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Sharman
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Shipley
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Shutt of Greetland
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Smith of Clifton
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Stoneham of Droxford
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Storey
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Taverne
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Teverson
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Thomas of Gresford
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Tope
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Tyler
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Wallace of Saltaire
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Wallace of Tankerness
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Willis of Knaresborough
LDem ------ no ------ The Earl of Glasgow
UUP ------ no ------ Lord Empey
Here are the peers who voted for the amendment
Bishop ------ aye ------ The Bishop of Chester
Bishop ------ aye ------ The Bishop of Exeter
Bishop ------ aye ------ The Bishop of Ripon and Leeds
Con ------ aye ------ Lord Newton of Braintree
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Butler-Sloss
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Coussins
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Cox
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Deech
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Finlay of Llandaff
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Grey-Thompson
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Hollins
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Howe of Idlicote
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Masham of Ilton
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Prashar
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Richardson of Calow
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Warnock
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lady Saltoun of Abernethy
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Aberdare
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Adebowale
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Alton of Liverpool
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Armstrong of Ilminster
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Best
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Elystan-Morgan
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Hall of Birkenhead
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Harries of Pentregarth
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Hastings of Scarisbrick
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Hylton
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Kerr of Kinlochard
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Laming
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Lloyd of Berwick
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Low of Dalston
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Palmer
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Patel
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Patel of Bradford
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Ramsbotham
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Rowe-Beddoe
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Scott of Foscote
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Walpole
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Williamson of Horton
Crossbench ------ aye ------ The Earl of Erroll
Crossbench ------ aye ------ The Earl of Sandwich
Crossbench ------ aye ------ The Earl of Stair
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Viscount Clancarty
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Viscount Colville of Culross
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Viscount Slim
DUP ------ aye ------ Lord Browne of Belmont
Ind Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Stoddart of Swindon
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Adams of Craigielea
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Andrews
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Armstrong of Hill Top
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Blackstone
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Corston
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Dean of Thornton-le-Fylde
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Donaghy
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Drake
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Farrington of Ribbleton
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Gale
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Gibson of Market Rasen
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Golding
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Gould of Potternewton
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Healy of Primrose Hill
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Henig
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Hollis of Heigham
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Howells of St Davids
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Hughes of Stretford
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Jones of Whitchurch
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Kennedy of The Shaws
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness King of Bow
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Kinnock of Holyhead
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Liddell of Coatdyke
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Lister of Burtersett
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Mallalieu
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Massey of Darwen
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness McDonagh
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness McIntosh of Hudnall
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Morgan of Ely
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Morgan of Huyton
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Morris of Yardley
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Nye
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Pitkeathley
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Prosser
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Ramsay of Cartvale
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Rendell of Babergh
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Royall of Blaisdon
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Scotland of Asthal
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Sherlock
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Smith of Basildon
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Symons of Vernham Dean
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Taylor of Bolton
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Thornton
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Turner of Camden
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Wall of New Barnet
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Wheeler
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Whitaker
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Worthington
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Adonis
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Ahmed
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Anderson of Swansea
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Bach
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Barnett
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Bassam of Brighton Teller
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Beecham
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Berkeley
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Bhattacharyya
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Bilston
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Borrie
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Boyd of Duncansby
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Bradley
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Bragg
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Brennan
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Brooke of Alverthorpe
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Brookman
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Brooks of Tremorfa
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Browne of Ladyton
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Campbell-Savours
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Clark of Windermere
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Clinton-Davis
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Collins of Highbury
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Cunningham of Felling
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Davies of Coity
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Davies of Oldham
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Donoughue
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Dubs
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Elder
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Evans of Parkside
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Evans of Temple Guiting
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Evans of Watford
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Faulkner of Worcester
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Filkin
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Foster of Bishop Auckland
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Foulkes of Cumnock
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Giddens
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Gilbert
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Glasman
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Goldsmith
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Gordon of Strathblane
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Graham of Edmonton
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Grantchester
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Harris of Haringey
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Harrison
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Hart of Chilton
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Haskel
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Hollick
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Howarth of Newport
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Howie of Troon
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Hoyle
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Hughes of Woodside
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Hunt of Kings Heath
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Irvine of Lairg
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Janner of Braunstone
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Jones
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Jordan
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Judd
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Kennedy of Southwark
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Kestenbaum
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord King of West Bromwich
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Kinnock
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Kirkhill
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Knight of Weymouth
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Layard
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Lea of Crondall
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Levy
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Liddle
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Lipsey
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Macdonald of Tradeston
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord MacKenzie of Culkein
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Mackenzie of Framwellgate
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Mandelson
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Martin of Springburn
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Maxton
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord McAvoy
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord McKenzie of Luton
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Mitchell
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Monks
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Morris of Aberavon
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Morris of Handsworth
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Myners
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord O'Neill of Clackmannan
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Pendry
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Peston
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Plant of Highfield
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Prescott
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Radice
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Rea
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Richard
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Rooker
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Rosser
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Rowlands
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Sawyer
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Sewel
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Snape
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Soley
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Stevenson of Balmacara
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Stone of Blackheath
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Taylor of Blackburn
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Temple-Morris
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Tomlinson
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Touhig
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Triesman
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Tunnicliffe Teller
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Warner
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord West of Spithead
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Whitty
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Williams of Baglan
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Williams of Elvel
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Winston
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Wood of Anfield
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Woolmer of Leeds
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Young of Norwood Green
Lab ------ aye ------ Viscount Chandos
Lab ------ aye ------ Viscount Hanworth
Lab ------ aye ------ Viscount Simon
LDem ------ aye ------ Baroness Doocey
LDem ------ aye ------ Baroness Tonge
LDem ------ aye ------ Lord Avebury
LDem ------ aye ------ Lord Carlile of Berriew
Other ------ aye ------ Lord Grenfell
PC ------ aye ------ Lord Wigley
LORD PANNICK
LORD ALTON OF LIVERPOOL
LORD NEWTON OF BRAINTREE
Amendment (12)
Page 125, line 5, at end insert—
“Social welfare law (No. 2)
(1) Civil legal services provided in respect of a social welfare decision relating to a benefit, allowance, payment, credit or pension under—
(a) the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992;
(b) the Jobseekers Act 1995;
(c) the State Pension Credit Act 2002;
(d) the Tax Credits Act 2002;
(e) the Welfare Reform Act 2007;
(f) the Welfare Reform Act 2012; or
(g) any other enactment relating to social security.
(2) For the purposes of sub-paragraph (1), “civil legal services” includes—
(a) independent advice or assistance for an appeal to a second-tier tribunal; and
(b) independent advice, assistance and representation at a higher court of such a decision.”
LORD LLOYD OF BERWICK
Read more: mylegal.proboards.com/index.cgi?action=display&board=frontline&thread=598&page=1#1403#ixzz1ofAgYU2s
Here are the peers who voted against the amendment
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Anelay of St Johns
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Berridge
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Bottomley of Nettlestone
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Browning
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Buscombe
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Byford
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Eaton
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Eccles of Moulton
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Fookes
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Gardner of Parkes
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Hanham
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Heyhoe Flint
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Hooper
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Jenkin of Kennington
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Knight of Collingtree
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Miller of Hendon
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Morris of Bolton
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Neville-Jones
Con ------ no ------ Baroness O'Cathain
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Perry of Southwark
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Rawlings
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Seccombe
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Shackleton of Belgravia
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Sharples
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Shephard of Northwold
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Stedman-Scott
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Stowell of Beeston
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Trumpington
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Verma
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Warsi
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Wheatcroft
Con ------ no ------ Baroness Wilcox
Con ------ no ------ Earl Attlee
Con ------ no ------ Earl Cathcart
Con ------ no ------ Earl Howe
Con ------ no ------ Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon
Con ------ no ------ Lord Ashton of Hyde
Con ------ no ------ Lord Astor of Hever
Con ------ no ------ Lord Baker of Dorking
Con ------ no ------ Lord Bates
Con ------ no ------ Lord Blencathra
Con ------ no ------ Lord Boswell of Aynho
Con ------ no ------ Lord Bowness
Con ------ no ------ Lord Brooke of Sutton Mandeville
Con ------ no ------ Lord Brougham and Vaux
Con ------ no ------ Lord Cavendish of Furness
Con ------ no ------ Lord Cope of Berkeley
Con ------ no ------ Lord Crathorne
Con ------ no ------ Lord Crickhowell
Con ------ no ------ Lord de Mauley
Con ------ no ------ Lord Deben
Con ------ no ------ Lord Denham
Con ------ no ------ Lord Dobbs
Con ------ no ------ Lord Eden of Winton
Con ------ no ------ Lord Edmiston
Con ------ no ------ Lord Elton
Con ------ no ------ Lord Faulks
Con ------ no ------ Lord Fellowes of West Stafford
Con ------ no ------ Lord Fink
Con ------ no ------ Lord Forsyth of Drumlean
Con ------ no ------ Lord Fowler
Con ------ no ------ Lord Framlingham
Con ------ no ------ Lord Freeman
Con ------ no ------ Lord Freud
Con ------ no ------ Lord Gardiner of Kimble
Con ------ no ------ Lord Geddes
Con ------ no ------ Lord Glendonbrook
Con ------ no ------ Lord Glentoran
Con ------ no ------ Lord Goodlad
Con ------ no ------ Lord Griffiths of Fforestfach
Con ------ no ------ Lord Hamilton of Epsom
Con ------ no ------ Lord Henley
Con ------ no ------ Lord Hill of Oareford
Con ------ no ------ Lord Howard of Rising
Con ------ no ------ Lord Howe of Aberavon
Con ------ no ------ Lord Hunt of Wirral
Con ------ no ------ Lord Inglewood
Con ------ no ------ Lord James of Blackheath
Con ------ no ------ Lord Jopling
Con ------ no ------ Lord King of Bridgwater
Con ------ no ------ Lord Lamont of Lerwick
Con ------ no ------ Lord Lawson of Blaby
Con ------ no ------ Lord Lexden
Con ------ no ------ Lord Lingfield
Con ------ no ------ Lord Luke
Con ------ no ------ Lord Lyell
Con ------ no ------ Lord MacGregor of Pulham Market
Con ------ no ------ Lord Marland
Con ------ no ------ Lord Marlesford
Con ------ no ------ Lord Mawhinney
Con ------ no ------ Lord Mayhew of Twysden
Con ------ no ------ Lord Moore of Lower Marsh
Con ------ no ------ Lord Norton of Louth
Con ------ no ------ Lord Patten
Con ------ no ------ Lord Popat
Con ------ no ------ Lord Ribeiro
Con ------ no ------ Lord Sanderson of Bowden
Con ------ no ------ Lord Sassoon
Con ------ no ------ Lord Selkirk of Douglas
Con ------ no ------ Lord Selsdon
Con ------ no ------ Lord Shaw of Northstead
Con ------ no ------ Lord Sheikh
Con ------ no ------ Lord Spicer
Con ------ no ------ Lord Strathclyde
Con ------ no ------ Lord Taylor of Holbeach
Con ------ no ------ Lord Trimble
Con ------ no ------ Lord True
Con ------ no ------ Lord Tugendhat
Con ------ no ------ Lord Wakeham
Con ------ no ------ Lord Wasserman
Con ------ no ------ The Duke of Montrose
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Arran
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Caithness
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Courtown
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Home
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Lindsay
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Liverpool
Con ------ no ------ The Earl of Shrewsbury
Con ------ no ------ Viscount Bridgeman
Con ------ no ------ Viscount Eccles
Con ------ no ------ Viscount Goschen
Con ------ no ------ Viscount Trenchard
Con ------ no ------ Viscount Ullswater
Con ------ no ------ Viscount Younger of Leckie
Crossbench ------ no ------ Lord Butler of Brockwell
Crossbench ------ no ------ Lord Greenway
Crossbench ------ no ------ Lord Maginnis of Drumglass
Crossbench ------ no ------ Lord Mawson
Crossbench ------ no ------ Lord Powell of Bayswater
Crossbench ------ no ------ Lord Rogan
Crossbench ------ no ------ Viscount Craigavon
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Barker
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Benjamin
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Bonham-Carter of Yarnbury
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Brinton
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Falkner of Margravine
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Garden of Frognal
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Hamwee
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Hussein-Ece
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Jolly
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Kramer
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Linklater of Butterstone
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Maddock
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Miller of Chilthorne Domer
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Northover
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Randerson
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Scott of Needham Market
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Sharp of Guildford
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Thomas of Winchester
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Tyler of Enfield
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Walmsley
LDem ------ no ------ Baroness Williams of Crosby
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Addington
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Alderdice
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Bradshaw
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Burnett
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Chidgey
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Clement-Jones
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Dholakia
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Dykes
LDem ------ no ------ Lord German
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Goodhart
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Hussain
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Jones of Cheltenham
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Loomba
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Macdonald of River Glaven
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames
LDem ------ no ------ Lord McNally
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Methuen
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Newby
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Palmer of Childs Hill
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Razzall
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Redesdale
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Rennard
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Roberts of Llandudno
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Sharkey
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Sharman
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Shipley
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Shutt of Greetland
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Smith of Clifton
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Stoneham of Droxford
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Storey
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Taverne
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Teverson
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Thomas of Gresford
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Tope
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Tyler
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Wallace of Saltaire
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Wallace of Tankerness
LDem ------ no ------ Lord Willis of Knaresborough
LDem ------ no ------ The Earl of Glasgow
UUP ------ no ------ Lord Empey
Here are the peers who voted for the amendment
Bishop ------ aye ------ The Bishop of Chester
Bishop ------ aye ------ The Bishop of Exeter
Bishop ------ aye ------ The Bishop of Ripon and Leeds
Con ------ aye ------ Lord Newton of Braintree
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Butler-Sloss
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Coussins
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Cox
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Deech
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Finlay of Llandaff
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Grey-Thompson
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Hollins
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Howe of Idlicote
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Masham of Ilton
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Prashar
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Richardson of Calow
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Baroness Warnock
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lady Saltoun of Abernethy
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Aberdare
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Adebowale
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Alton of Liverpool
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Armstrong of Ilminster
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Best
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Elystan-Morgan
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Hall of Birkenhead
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Harries of Pentregarth
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Hastings of Scarisbrick
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Hylton
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Kerr of Kinlochard
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Laming
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Lloyd of Berwick
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Low of Dalston
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Palmer
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Patel
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Patel of Bradford
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Ramsbotham
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Rowe-Beddoe
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Scott of Foscote
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Walpole
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Lord Williamson of Horton
Crossbench ------ aye ------ The Earl of Erroll
Crossbench ------ aye ------ The Earl of Sandwich
Crossbench ------ aye ------ The Earl of Stair
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Viscount Clancarty
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Viscount Colville of Culross
Crossbench ------ aye ------ Viscount Slim
DUP ------ aye ------ Lord Browne of Belmont
Ind Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Stoddart of Swindon
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Adams of Craigielea
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Andrews
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Armstrong of Hill Top
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Blackstone
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Corston
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Dean of Thornton-le-Fylde
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Donaghy
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Drake
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Farrington of Ribbleton
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Gale
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Gibson of Market Rasen
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Golding
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Gould of Potternewton
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Healy of Primrose Hill
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Henig
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Hollis of Heigham
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Howells of St Davids
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Hughes of Stretford
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Jones of Whitchurch
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Kennedy of The Shaws
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness King of Bow
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Kinnock of Holyhead
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Liddell of Coatdyke
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Lister of Burtersett
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Mallalieu
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Massey of Darwen
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness McDonagh
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness McIntosh of Hudnall
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Morgan of Ely
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Morgan of Huyton
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Morris of Yardley
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Nye
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Pitkeathley
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Prosser
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Ramsay of Cartvale
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Rendell of Babergh
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Royall of Blaisdon
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Scotland of Asthal
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Sherlock
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Smith of Basildon
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Symons of Vernham Dean
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Taylor of Bolton
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Thornton
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Turner of Camden
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Wall of New Barnet
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Wheeler
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Whitaker
Lab ------ aye ------ Baroness Worthington
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Adonis
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Ahmed
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Anderson of Swansea
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Bach
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Barnett
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Bassam of Brighton Teller
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Beecham
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Berkeley
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Bhattacharyya
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Bilston
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Borrie
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Boyd of Duncansby
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Bradley
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Bragg
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Brennan
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Brooke of Alverthorpe
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Brookman
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Brooks of Tremorfa
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Browne of Ladyton
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Campbell-Savours
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Clark of Windermere
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Clinton-Davis
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Collins of Highbury
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Cunningham of Felling
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Davies of Coity
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Davies of Oldham
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Donoughue
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Dubs
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Elder
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Evans of Parkside
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Evans of Temple Guiting
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Evans of Watford
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Faulkner of Worcester
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Filkin
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Foster of Bishop Auckland
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Foulkes of Cumnock
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Giddens
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Gilbert
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Glasman
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Goldsmith
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Gordon of Strathblane
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Graham of Edmonton
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Grantchester
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Harris of Haringey
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Harrison
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Hart of Chilton
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Haskel
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Hollick
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Howarth of Newport
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Howie of Troon
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Hoyle
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Hughes of Woodside
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Hunt of Kings Heath
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Irvine of Lairg
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Janner of Braunstone
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Jones
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Jordan
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Judd
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Kennedy of Southwark
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Kestenbaum
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord King of West Bromwich
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Kinnock
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Kirkhill
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Knight of Weymouth
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Layard
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Lea of Crondall
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Levy
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Liddle
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Lipsey
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Macdonald of Tradeston
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord MacKenzie of Culkein
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Mackenzie of Framwellgate
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Mandelson
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Martin of Springburn
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Maxton
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord McAvoy
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord McKenzie of Luton
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Mitchell
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Monks
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Morris of Aberavon
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Morris of Handsworth
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Myners
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord O'Neill of Clackmannan
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Pendry
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Peston
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Plant of Highfield
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Prescott
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Radice
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Rea
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Richard
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Rooker
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Rosser
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Rowlands
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Sawyer
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Sewel
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Snape
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Soley
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Stevenson of Balmacara
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Stone of Blackheath
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Taylor of Blackburn
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Temple-Morris
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Tomlinson
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Touhig
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Triesman
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Tunnicliffe Teller
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Warner
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord West of Spithead
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Whitty
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Williams of Baglan
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Williams of Elvel
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Winston
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Wood of Anfield
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Woolmer of Leeds
Lab ------ aye ------ Lord Young of Norwood Green
Lab ------ aye ------ Viscount Chandos
Lab ------ aye ------ Viscount Hanworth
Lab ------ aye ------ Viscount Simon
LDem ------ aye ------ Baroness Doocey
LDem ------ aye ------ Baroness Tonge
LDem ------ aye ------ Lord Avebury
LDem ------ aye ------ Lord Carlile of Berriew
Other ------ aye ------ Lord Grenfell
PC ------ aye ------ Lord Wigley